Bear Mattress vs Brooklyn Bedding

In-depth comparison, January 2019

Bear Mattress vs Brooklyn Bedding: Online Mattress Comparison

Bear Mattress

bearmattress.com
7.2
Overall Score
Compare Bear Mattress vs another brand

Brooklyn Bedding

brooklynbedding.com
6.5
Overall Score
Compare Brooklyn Bedding vs another brand
Bear Mattress vs. Brooklyn Bedding: Pros and Cons of Each
PROS
CONS
PROS
CONS
  • No significant cons
Bear Mattress vs. Brooklyn Bedding: Comparison Summary
Advantage
Bear Mattress
Criteria
Brooklyn Bedding
Advantage
7.2
Overall Score
Overall Score
6.5
Overall Score
3.0 stars – See brand >
Brand Popularity
3.0 stars – See brand >
4.0 stars – 1 review
Price Competitiveness
3.0 stars – 1 review
4.7 stars – 3 reviews
Cooling Features
4.3 stars – 3 reviews
4.5 stars – 2 reviews
Motion Isolation Features
3.5 stars – 2 reviews
2.0 stars – 2 reviews
Hypoallergenic Mattress Features
3.0 stars – 2 reviews
4.0 stars – 2 reviews
Eco-friendly Materials
3.5 stars – 2 reviews
5.0 stars – 1 review
Mattress Guarantee Policy
5.0 stars – 1 review
3.0 stars – 1 review
Side Sleeper Support
5.0 stars – 1 review
3.0 stars – 1 review
Back Sleeper Support
5.0 stars – 1 review
3.0 stars – 1 review
Stomach Sleeper Support
5.0 stars – 1 review
4.0 stars – 1 review
Eco-friendliness
4.0 stars – 1 review
Advantage
Bear Mattress
Shipping & Returns Policies
Brooklyn Bedding
Advantage
Yes
Free Shipping Policies
Yes
Yes
Returns & Exchanges Policies
Yes
Yes
International Shipping Policies
Yes
Advantage
Bear Mattress
Payment Options
Brooklyn Bedding
Advantage
Unlikely
Apple Pay Support
Unlikely
Unlikely
Paypal Support
Unlikely
Unlikely
Debit & Prepaid Card Support
Unlikely
Yes
Financing Options
Yes
Advantage
Bear Mattress
Discount Policies
Brooklyn Bedding
Advantage
Yes
Official Coupons Support
Unlikely
Availability of Sales and Promotions
Yes
Unlikely
Student Discount Policies
Yes
Unlikely
Military Discount Policies
Yes
Unlikely
Senior Discount Policies
Unlikely
Unlikely
Birthday Discount Policies
Unlikely
Yes
Promo Code Support
Yes
Unlikely
Black Friday Page
Unlikely
Yes
Cyber Monday Page
Unlikely
Advantage
Bear Mattress
Customer Service Features
Brooklyn Bedding
Advantage
Social Media Presence
Yes
In-home Trial Support
Yes
Yes
Contact Information Availability
Yes
Advantage
Bear Mattress
Financing Options
Brooklyn Bedding
Advantage
Yes
Affirm Financing Support
Yes
Unlikely
Afterpay Financing Support
Unlikely
Advantage
Bear Mattress
Marketing Programs
Brooklyn Bedding
Advantage
Yes
Affiliate Programs
Yes
Bear Mattress
View brand
21 active offers >>
Brooklyn Bedding
View brand
8 active offers >>

Bear Mattress vs. Brooklyn Bedding: Comparison Details

Best Price Competitiveness – Winner: Bear Mattress
4.0 stars

Bear Mattress has competitive pricing, and is priced a bit lower than its competitors. We looked at Bear Mattress' pricing for one or more popular products within its industry, then compared Bear Mattress' prices vs. other similar mattress-in-a-box brands. Based on this analysis, Bear Mattress turned out to be slightly less expensive than other brands in the mattress-in-a-box industry.

Here's how Bear Mattress' prices compare with its competitors:

Basic Queen Mattress: $740.00 (vs. average industry price of $882.40)

Please refer to Bear Mattress' website for more details on their products and pricing, or review our updated price comparison grid to compare Bear Mattress' prices with competitor brands in more detail.

Last reviewed January 20, 2019. Read 1 price point review.

3.0 stars

Brooklyn Bedding's pricing is close to the average within its industry. We looked at Brooklyn Bedding's pricing for one or more popular products within its industry, then compared Brooklyn Bedding's prices vs. other similar bed-in-a-box brands. Based on this analysis, Brooklyn Bedding has pricing that falls near the average when compared to the rest of the direct-to-consumer mattresses industry.

Here's how Brooklyn Bedding's prices compare with its competitors:

Basic Queen Mattress: $949.00 (vs. average industry price of $882.40)

Please refer to Brooklyn Bedding's website for more details on their products and pricing, or review our updated price comparison grid to compare Brooklyn Bedding's prices with competitor brands in more detail.

Last reviewed January 20, 2019. Read 1 price point review.

Bear Mattress
View brand
Brooklyn Bedding
View brand
Best Cooling Features – Winner: Bear Mattress
5.0 stars

Tuck.com analyzed over 3,000 reviews from 22 different sources to create their review. They gave Bear Mattress a score of Very Good (with only Excellent being higher) for Temperature Neutrality, saying "The Bear hybrid mattress will be more temperature neutral than the all foam Bear mattress."

Mattress Guides says that the Beat Mattress should be good for hot sleepers, given "On top of it lies a layer of graphite gel- infused memory foam, which improves the thermal exchange by having a cooling effect of 7 times the regular foam."

Last reviewed November 7, 2018. Read all 2 cooling features reviews.

4.0 stars

Tuck.com gave Brooklyn Bedding a rating of Very Good (the second highest rating) for Temperature Neutrality, saying, "Good airflow throughout the coil layer allows the Signature to sleep cool and comfortable for most." 

Over at Mattress Clarity, they rated Brooklyn Bedding's "Doesn't Sleep Hot" factor as 4.2/5, and supported this by saying, "The TitanFlex promotes cooling and the coils are great for airflow. You shouldn’t be sleeping hot on the Signature."

Sleepopolis came to a similar conclusion, saying, "The proprietary TitanFlex foam in the comfort and transition layers helps to keep the mattress cool while the individually wrapped coils encourage air flow throughout the structure."

Last reviewed November 7, 2018. Read all 2 cooling features reviews.

Bear Mattress
View brand
Brooklyn Bedding
View brand
Best Motion Isolation Features – Winner: Bear Mattress
5.0 stars

When it comes to motion isolation, Mattress Guide gave a positive review, saying "Motion transfer with the Bear Mattress is quite minimal – almost none at all. Which makes it an excellent option for couples if one of them if easily disturbed by shuffling or movement from the other one."

Tuck.com, who created their review after analyzing over 3,000 reviews from 22 sources, concluded similarly. They gave Bear Mattresses a rating of Very Good (with only Excellent being higher) for motion isolation, saying "According to owners, the Bear Mattress absorbs and isolates motion to a significant extent, and many report a reduced number of nighttime sleep disruptions."

The Sleep Judge agreed, and even performed a weight drop test. They said, "Where the Bear lacks in edge support it makes up for in motion isolation... I used a 20-pound medicine ball and held it at eye-level. When I dropped it onto the bed, it only bounced very slightly before coming to rest. I  then placed the ball on one side of the bed and dropped an identical ball on the other side. There was very minimal disruption of the resting ball. You could also see clearly that the bed quickly bounced back when the ball was dropped." 

Last reviewed November 7, 2018. Read all 2 motion isolation reviews.

4.0 stars

When it comes to restless sleepers, you want to make sure your mattress prevents motion transfer. Brooklyn Bedding got a rating of Very Good (the second highest rating) for it's Motion Isolation factor from Tuck.com, who analyzed 392 reviews for their review. They said, "Due to its 4" all-foam comfort system, the Signature isolates and minimizes motion better than most hybrids."

Mattress Clarity offered a less warm review, saying, "Testing the mattress, I experienced a little bit of motion transfer. The cup was definitely affected as I moved near it. The motion isolation is about average and those who sleep with a partner may feel some motion transfer.   If you sleep with a partner, this is just something to consider." They rated it 3.7/5, 

Sleepopolis said, "While the 4 inch drop showed a surprisingly small amount of disturbance, the 8 and 12 inch drops showed the average amount of interference that I’d normally expect from a hybrid design. Given the bounce of the TitanFlex foam and pocketed coil system, it’s no surprise that there was some slight motion disturbance across the surface. That being said, the motion transfer is nothing major and means you probably won’t be too bothered by your partner tossing and turning at night." 

Last reviewed November 7, 2018. Read all 2 motion isolation reviews.

Bear Mattress
View brand
Brooklyn Bedding
View brand
Best Hypoallergenic Mattress Features – Winner: Brooklyn Bedding
2.0 stars

If you have allergies, Bear Mattresses may not be well suited to you. We reached out to their support team via chat and the representative said "It is not hypo-allergenic but there have been no reported reactions"

Last reviewed November 7, 2018. Read all 2 hypoallergenic features reviews.

3.0 stars

If you have latex allergies, In a recent chat, a Brooklyn Bedding support representative said, "Nearly all of our mattresses now feature TitanFlex™ foam, a patented latex alternative... TitanFlex is 100% hypoallergenic and is CertiPure US certified, which means there are no toxic or harmful chemicals used in the material."

However, seeing as some of their mattresses may use other materials, those allergic to latex should approach them warily. For people with other allergies, the representative said, "We haven't heard anything regarding allergic reactions with our mattresses."

Last reviewed November 7, 2018. Read all 2 hypoallergenic features reviews.

Bear Mattress
View brand
Brooklyn Bedding
View brand
Best Eco-friendly Materials – Winner: Bear Mattress
4.0 stars

We learned from a support team chat conversation that Bear Mattresses use Certi-Pur certified foams, and that they are not organic.

Sleep Cupid's review of Bear Mattresses says that "...its materials are sourced in the United States. The beds themselves are also assembled within the country. The foam that is used in the Bear Mattress is also quite safe with very little off-gassing. It is CertiPUR-US certified, which means it is free of toxic materials and is also safe for the environment. It’s manufactured without the use of heavy metals and without releasing noxious chemicals into the atmosphere."

Last reviewed November 7, 2018. Read all 2 eco-friendliness reviews.

4.0 stars

According to Brooklyn Bedding's website, "We use the safest materials in the mattress industry, guaranteed. Our foam is CertiPur Certified, which means it's toxin free and meets the highest health standards in the industry." 

In regard to a question about potentially toxic fire deterrents, their FAQ section says, "Brooklyn Bedding does not use chemical fire sprays or chemical retardants in our mattresses. We do use the highest quality fire retardant socks—a fabric made of a non-woven silica/rayon/polyester/cotton blend. 

Last reviewed November 7, 2018. Read all 2 eco-friendliness reviews.

Bear Mattress
View brand
Brooklyn Bedding
View brand
Best Mattress Guarantee Policy – Tie
5.0 stars

Yes, Bear Mattress does offer a comfort guarantee or trial period. You can read more about Bear Mattress's customer satisfaction policies on their website on their purchase and terms page.

Good luck with your shopping there! If you can't find the information in the link above, you might be able to find more information on Bear Mattress's homepage here.

Last reviewed June 27, 2017. Read 1 mattress guarantee review.

Bear Mattress
View brand
Brooklyn Bedding
View brand
Best Side Sleeper Support – Winner: Brooklyn Bedding
3.0 stars

We looked, but could not find any info on if Bear Mattress mattresses are good for side sleepers. You might want to check their FAQ page for any updates on recommended mattresses for your sleep position.

Also, we recommend checking Bear Mattress's homepage for additional information.

Last reviewed August 1, 2018. Read all 2 side sleeping reviews.

5.0 stars

Yes, Brooklyn Bedding mattresses are good for side sleepers.

You can find out more about Brooklyn Bedding's recommended mattresses for side sleepers on their customer service page.

Hope this helps! If you can't find the information in the link above, you might be able to find more information on Brooklyn Bedding's homepage here.

Last reviewed August 1, 2018. Read all 2 side sleeping reviews.

Bear Mattress
View brand
Brooklyn Bedding
View brand
Best Back Sleeper Support – Winner: Brooklyn Bedding
3.0 stars

We looked, but could not find any info on if Bear Mattress mattresses are good for back sleepers. You might want to check their FAQ page for any updates on recommended mattresses for your sleep position.

Also, we recommend checking Bear Mattress's homepage for additional information.

Last reviewed August 1, 2018. Read all 2 back sleeping reviews.

5.0 stars

Yes, Brooklyn Bedding mattresses are good for back sleepers. Brooklyn Bedding provides guidelines on optimal sleeping positions for their mattresses on their FAQ page.

Hope you find the information you need there! You can also check out Brooklyn Bedding's homepage for more information on their ideal mattress for back sleepers.

Last reviewed August 1, 2018. Read all 2 back sleeping reviews.

Bear Mattress
View brand
Brooklyn Bedding
View brand
Best Stomach Sleeper Support – Winner: Brooklyn Bedding
3.0 stars

We looked, but could not find any info on if Bear Mattress mattresses are good for stomach sleepers. You might want to check their FAQ page for any updates on recommended mattresses for your sleep position.

Also, we recommend checking Bear Mattress's homepage for additional information.

Last reviewed August 1, 2018. Read all 2 stomach sleeping reviews.

5.0 stars

Yes, Brooklyn Bedding mattresses are good for stomach sleepers. Brooklyn Bedding provides guidelines on optimal sleeping positions for their mattresses on their FAQ page.

Hope you find the information you need there! You can also check out Brooklyn Bedding's homepage for more information on their ideal mattress for stomach sleepers.

Last reviewed August 1, 2018. Read all 2 stomach sleeping reviews.

Bear Mattress
View brand
Brooklyn Bedding
View brand
Best Eco-friendliness – Tie
4.0 stars

We looked, but could not find any info on if Bear Mattress supports any kind of eco-friendly cause or effort. You might want to check their FAQ page for any updates on which eco-friendly initiatives, if any, they support.

Also, we recommend checking Bear Mattress's homepage for additional information.

Last reviewed December 10, 2018. Read all 2 eco-friendly causes reviews.

4.0 stars

It's not clear whether Brooklyn Bedding supports any type of eco-friendly causes. It might be best to visit their site to get the latest, up-to-date info on Brooklyn Bedding's eco-friendliness, here.

You can always try Brooklyn Bedding's homepage as well to see if they have additional information posted there. They may occasionally post coupon codes and deals there, too: link.

Last reviewed December 10, 2018. Read all 2 eco-friendly causes reviews.

Bear Mattress
View brand
Brooklyn Bedding
View brand
Best Free Shipping Policies – Tie
Yes

Last reviewed November 27, 2018. Read all 2 free shipping reviews.

Yes

Last reviewed November 4, 2018. Read all 2 free shipping reviews.

Best Returns & Exchanges Policies – Tie
Yes

Last reviewed June 27, 2017. Read 1 free returns & exchanges review.

Yes

Last reviewed June 27, 2017. Read 1 free returns & exchanges review.

Best Apple Pay Support – Tie
Unlikely

Last reviewed November 7, 2018. Read all 2 Apple Pay reviews.

Unlikely

Last reviewed October 31, 2018. Read all 2 Apple Pay reviews.

Best In-home Trial Support – Tie
Yes

Last reviewed August 1, 2018. Read all 2 free in-home trials reviews.

Yes

Last reviewed August 1, 2018. Read all 2 free in-home trials reviews.

Best Financing Options – Tie
Yes

Last reviewed August 2, 2018. Read all 2 financing options reviews.

Yes

Last reviewed August 2, 2018. Read all 2 financing options reviews.

Best Official Coupons Support – Winner: Bear Mattress
Yes

Last reviewed June 27, 2017. Read 1 official coupons page review.

Unlikely

Last reviewed June 27, 2017. Read 1 official coupons page review.

Best Availability of Sales and Promotions – Winner: Brooklyn Bedding
Does Bear Mattress offer sales?
Not rated yet.
Yes

Last reviewed June 27, 2017. Read 1 sales review.

Best Student Discount Policies – Winner: Brooklyn Bedding
Unlikely

Last reviewed June 27, 2017. Read 1 student discounts review.

Yes

Last reviewed November 4, 2018. Read 1 student discounts review.

Best Military Discount Policies – Winner: Brooklyn Bedding
Unlikely

Last reviewed August 22, 2018. Read 1 military discounts review.

Yes

Last reviewed November 4, 2018. Read 1 military discounts review.

Best Senior Discount Policies – Tie
Unlikely

Last reviewed June 27, 2017. Read 1 senior discounts review.

Unlikely

Last reviewed June 27, 2017. Read 1 senior discounts review.

Best Birthday Discount Policies – Tie
Unlikely

Last reviewed June 27, 2017. Read 1 birthday discounts review.

Unlikely

Last reviewed June 27, 2017. Read 1 birthday discounts review.

Best International Shipping Policies – Tie
Yes

Last reviewed August 1, 2018. Read all 2 international shipping reviews.

Yes

Last reviewed August 1, 2018. Read all 2 international shipping reviews.

Best Affiliate Programs – Tie
Yes

Last reviewed July 5, 2018. Read all 2 affiliate programs reviews.

Yes

Last reviewed July 5, 2018. Read all 2 affiliate programs reviews.

Best Paypal Support – Tie
Does Bear Mattress accept PayPal?
Unlikely

Last reviewed November 27, 2018. Read all 2 PayPal reviews.

Unlikely

Last reviewed November 27, 2018. Read all 2 PayPal reviews.

Best Social Media Presence – Tie
Not rated yet.
Not rated yet.
Best Debit & Prepaid Card Support – Tie
Unlikely

Last reviewed June 29, 2018. Read all 2 debit & prepaid cards reviews.

Unlikely

Last reviewed November 4, 2018. Read all 2 debit & prepaid cards reviews.

Best Promo Code Support – Tie
Yes

Last reviewed June 25, 2018. Read all 2 promo codes reviews.

Yes

Last reviewed June 25, 2018. Read all 2 promo codes reviews.

Best Affirm Financing Support – Tie
Yes

Last reviewed January 21, 2019. Read all 2 Affirm financing reviews.

Yes

Last reviewed January 21, 2019. Read all 2 Affirm financing reviews.

Best Afterpay Financing Support – Tie
Unlikely

Last reviewed November 27, 2018. Read all 2 Afterpay financing reviews.

Unlikely

Last reviewed November 27, 2018. Read all 2 Afterpay financing reviews.

Best Contact Information Availability – Tie
Yes

Last reviewed July 9, 2018. Read all 2 contact information reviews.

Yes

Last reviewed July 9, 2018. Read all 2 contact information reviews.

Best Teacher Discount Policies – Winner: Brooklyn Bedding
Unlikely

Last reviewed August 2, 2018. Read all 2 teacher discounts reviews.

Yes

Last reviewed August 2, 2018. Read all 2 teacher discounts reviews.

Best Black Friday Page – Tie
Unlikely

Last reviewed November 27, 2018. Read all 2 Black Friday ad reviews.

Unlikely

Last reviewed November 27, 2018. Read all 2 Black Friday ad reviews.

Best Cyber Monday Page – Winner: Bear Mattress
Yes

Last reviewed November 27, 2018. Read all 2 Cyber Monday ad reviews.

Unlikely

Last reviewed November 27, 2018. Read all 2 Cyber Monday ad reviews.